Buying One Industrial Unit or Building a Portfolio
Owning several industrial units can spread rental income across different tenants. It can also tie a substantial amount of capital to one building. Both deserve attention before a portfolio purchase is described as diversified.
A 24 September EdgeProp report describes seven freehold B1 units at Tag A in Tagore Industrial Estate, marketed by Knight Frank and offered individually or as a portfolio. They span approximately 22,238 sq ft and carry a combined guide price of S$17.8 million, or about S$800 psf. The units are fully leased, the sales are subject to those tenancies, and the expression of interest closes on 29 October.
The same report includes a separate Kovan HDB shop, bringing the overall offering to S$21 million. The industrial portfolio's own guide price is S$17.8 million. Keeping those figures separate is essential when making a comparison.
Several tenants can still share the same exposure
If one tenant leaves a portfolio, the others may continue providing income. That is a real advantage over relying on a single occupier for every dollar of rent. How much protection it provides depends on the income contributed by each tenant.
I would map the rent by unit and lease expiry, and look at how the occupiers' businesses are related. Five tenants in closely connected trades may respond similarly to a downturn. Several leases expiring within a short period can also create a concentrated renewal task.
Units in one building remain exposed to common factors such as access, management costs and competing supply in the location. A spread of tenant names should therefore be considered alongside the shared property risks.
Compare the income after the bills
Freehold B1 industrial property can appeal to investors who want a long holding horizon, and I have written about why freehold B1 launches keep selling out. The holding case still needs to explain the return at the price being paid.
For each unit, I would check the passing rent, deposit, remaining tenancy period and responsibility for repairs. Then I would allow for the owner's maintenance charges, property tax, foreseeable works and a reasonable vacancy provision. Financing needs a separate assessment based on actual bank terms.
For a hypothetical portfolio collecting S$40,000 a month, an occupier paying S$12,000 contributes 30% of the income. Six months without that rent would remove S$72,000 of receipts before fitting out or marketing for a replacement. The headline occupancy rate would not show the full effect.
The portfolio calculation should be built from the individual leases. Using one assumed market rent across all units can conceal differences in access, floor level and layout that affect what each occupier will pay.
Decide how you might sell later
Separate strata units may offer useful exit choices. An owner could consider selling part of the holding, subject to financing arrangements and any applicable restrictions, rather than having to find a purchaser for the entire portfolio.
That flexibility deserves a unit-by-unit check. Which units have the broadest occupier appeal? Which require a larger cheque? Would an owner-occupier need to wait for vacant possession? An existing tenant can support investment income while affecting when another business can move in.
I would also check whether buying several units actually improves the terms offered. A package is an investment structure, and its merits need to be established from the price and documents. The seller's willingness to offer units together does not establish a discount.
The five-point framework I use for commercial and industrial investments gives the exit the same weight as location, tenure, specification and financing, which matters here. And if the units serve logistics or light industrial occupiers, my look at the warehouse upgrades changing Singapore industrial property covers the specification questions those tenants are likely to ask.
For a first industrial investment, one well-understood unit may be easier to manage and finance. An industrial property portfolio in Singapore becomes more attractive when the investor has the capital reserves and a clear plan for renewals, vacancies and eventual disposal. Before deciding, put both options into the same ownership budget and see which one you would be comfortable carrying through a weaker leasing period.
Sources
Cover photo: industrial buildings along Upper Paya Lebar Road near Tai Seng MRT station, shown for illustration (not Tag A). Photo: Jnzl's Photos, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Comments